
User submitted reviews
Review by Hernan RiveraBest Saddle by Hernan RiveraNorthridge2 of 2 customers found this review helpful.Ive always loved Brooks saddles. Ive ridden the Swift, the classic B17 and now the Cambium and let me say that the Cambium by far is my favorite right out the box. The break-in time is practically non-existent and the overall ride and feel is awesome, not to mention theyre super light. Thanks Brooks, you guys are killing it.
Reviewed 9/14/2018Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Hernan Rivera was helpful/No, review by Hernan Rivera was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Ive always loved Brooks saddles. Ive ridden the Swift, the classic B17 and now the Cambium and let me say that the Cambium by far is my favorite right out the box. The break-in time is practically non-existent and the overall ride and feel is awesome, not to mention theyre super light. Thanks Brooks, you guys are killing it.
Review by AnonymousSolid, comfortableby AnonymousCycling EnthusiastLynnwood, WAMy first Brooks saddle. For not having any padding I find it just as comfortable as my old padded saddle. Haven't done any longish rides on it, but for my commuting distances it's great. Chose it over a leather version since it's water proof.
Reviewed 6/16/2020Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
My first Brooks saddle. For not having any padding I find it just as comfortable as my old padded saddle. Haven't done any longish rides on it, but for my commuting distances it's great. Chose it over a leather version since it's water proof.
Review by AnonymousBrooks legacy continues by AnonymousHudson Valley, NY1 of 1 customers found this review helpful.Ive had a Brooks B17 for over 15 years. The C17 is equally comfortable, without the break in period, and aesthetically nice enough to be used on any bike- even high end road. 110% recommend this product.
Reviewed 4/3/2020Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Ive had a Brooks B17 for over 15 years. The C17 is equally comfortable, without the break in period, and aesthetically nice enough to be used on any bike- even high end road. 110% recommend this product.
Review by Anonymousnice saddleby AnonymousCycling EnthusiastMichigan2 of 2 customers found this review helpful.saddles are insanely personal. Tried many but have settled on the Brooks C17 over some that cost 3x as much
When you find one that works stay with it regardless of price, looks or weight. I currently have it on 3 bikes
Reviewed 6/7/2019Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
saddles are insanely personal. Tried many but have settled on the Brooks C17 over some that cost 3x as much
When you find one that works stay with it regardless of price, looks or weight. I currently have it on 3 bikes
Review by Nor''eastahAmazing Saddle...Very comfortable fit to my bottom. I liked it so much that purchased another one.by Nor''eastahCycling EnthusiastNew Paltz, NYUse every day. Seems to be a perfect match for me. The cutout works well but the saddle material flexes really good, so I'm not sure you need it. After buying this saddle also tried the B17 leather and that is an excellent saddle as well. I really like that WESTERN BIKE WORK matched the competitors price.
Reviewed 5/3/2019Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Nor''eastah was helpful/No, review by Nor''eastah was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Use every day. Seems to be a perfect match for me. The cutout works well but the saddle material flexes really good, so I'm not sure you need it. After buying this saddle also tried the B17 leather and that is an excellent saddle as well. I really like that WESTERN BIKE WORK matched the competitors price.
Review by DanComfortable all-weather ridingby DanPORTLAND0 of 1 customers found this review helpful.Saddles can be very personal. The wider seat fits me well.
Reviewed 7/17/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Dan was helpful/No, review by Dan was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Saddles can be very personal. The wider seat fits me well.
Review by KennfdVery comfortable, no break in requiredby KennfdCycling EnthusiastConnecticut1 of 1 customers found this review helpful.I wanted a Brooks saddle for my hybrid bike to replace the stock saddle. The Cambiun rubber construction appealed to me more than the leather. As soon as I sat on it I knew I made the right choice, very comfortable saddle and looks good too.
Reviewed 11/15/2018Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Kennfd was helpful/No, review by Kennfd was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I wanted a Brooks saddle for my hybrid bike to replace the stock saddle. The Cambiun rubber construction appealed to me more than the leather. As soon as I sat on it I knew I made the right choice, very comfortable saddle and looks good too.
Review by AnonymousExcellent saddle. Very happy with it and no break-in period. All weather so no worries in the rain and mud.by AnonymousCycling EnthusiastHillsboro OR4 of 4 customers found this review helpful.Saddle is on a gravelcyclocross bike. I put in long rides and have a few hundred miles on the saddle. Used on gravel, single track and tarmac. It was comfortable from day one. Just a few minor angle adjustments on the first ride. Extremely comfortable on long rides. I do not notice any discomfort during or after the ride.
Reviewed 8/21/2018Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Saddle is on a gravelcyclocross bike. I put in long rides and have a few hundred miles on the saddle. Used on gravel, single track and tarmac. It was comfortable from day one. Just a few minor angle adjustments on the first ride. Extremely comfortable on long rides. I do not notice any discomfort during or after the ride.
Review by RocketJohnLooks to be a great saddle, may be 5 stars once I can get a few hundred miles on it.by RocketJohnCycling EnthusiastLake Winnebago, MO1 of 2 customers found this review helpful.Slapped this on my classic Lemond road bike, looks great and feels great.
Reviewed 2/8/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by RocketJohn was helpful/No, review by RocketJohn was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Slapped this on my classic Lemond road bike, looks great and feels great.
Review by trogonGreat long distance saddle, comfortable from day 1.by trogonCompetitive RacerWisconsin3 of 3 customers found this review helpful.I bought this saddle for my wife who is a long distance cyclist. She normally rides Selle Anatomica but leather stretches and the saddle needed to be replaced. Took a chance with this model and she loves it. Comfortable on the first day and it continues to be comfortable no matter the distance.
Reviewed 6/18/2018Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by trogon was helpful/No, review by trogon was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I bought this saddle for my wife who is a long distance cyclist. She normally rides Selle Anatomica but leather stretches and the saddle needed to be replaced. Took a chance with this model and she loves it. Comfortable on the first day and it continues to be comfortable no matter the distance.
Review by AnonymousBest saddle I've tried. by Anonymous3 of 3 customers found this review helpful.I've tried at least 15 different saddles ranging from $40 wtb to $250 selle smp. Brooks has the best feel. The saddle is quite flexible and behaves as a shock absorber. There is some break in time but nearly as much as leather, mine is starting to form after just a few rides.
Reviewed 6/7/2018Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I've tried at least 15 different saddles ranging from $40 wtb to $250 selle smp. Brooks has the best feel. The saddle is quite flexible and behaves as a shock absorber. There is some break in time but nearly as much as leather, mine is starting to form after just a few rides.
Review by MattGreat store!by Mattsanta cruz0 of 2 customers found this review helpful.Got a great price!
Reviewed 9/3/2018Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Matt was helpful/No, review by Matt was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Got a great price!
Review by Art in COI like this saddle.by Art in COCycling EnthusiastErie, COI have two C17s for my fat bikes, and two C15s for my gravel bikes. I have found them to be very comfortable in those applications. They are far more flexible than their leather counterparts, and they are weather proof. They also have cut outs, so maybe a little less pressure in sensitive areas. My journey to the C17 has taken my through a number of different saddles, many far more expensive, but none as comfortable for me as the C17 and C15. Not light, by any means, but I value comfort over saving a few grams any day.
Reviewed 2/16/2023Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Art in CO was helpful/No, review by Art in CO was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I have two C17s for my fat bikes, and two C15s for my gravel bikes. I have found them to be very comfortable in those applications. They are far more flexible than their leather counterparts, and they are weather proof. They also have cut outs, so maybe a little less pressure in sensitive areas. My journey to the C17 has taken my through a number of different saddles, many far more expensive, but none as comfortable for me as the C17 and C15. Not light, by any means, but I value comfort over saving a few grams any day.
Review by Art in COComfortable option to a B17by Art in COCycling EnthusiastErie, CO2 of 2 customers found this review helpful.I bought this to replace a B17 on my fat bike. I have been trying out cutaway saddles after my doctor suggested that bicycling with regular saddles might be having some negative health consequences. Roughly the same shape as a B17, it is much more flexible, and therefore more comfortable over uneven terrain. It is waterproof as well so no Proofide needed. Not light by any means, but I am not concerned with the weight. I also think the price is reasonable. It is certainly worth considering.
Reviewed 5/2/2022Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Art in CO was helpful/No, review by Art in CO was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I bought this to replace a B17 on my fat bike. I have been trying out cutaway saddles after my doctor suggested that bicycling with regular saddles might be having some negative health consequences. Roughly the same shape as a B17, it is much more flexible, and therefore more comfortable over uneven terrain. It is waterproof as well so no Proofide needed. Not light by any means, but I am not concerned with the weight. I also think the price is reasonable. It is certainly worth considering.
Review by AnonymousGood Wider Width Saddle Well-madeby AnonymousCycling EnthusiastHuntington Beach CA3 of 3 customers found this review helpful.I bought this saddle to replace a lighter, thinner Italian saddle which was beautiful cosmetically, but was doing me no favors to my nether regions. This saddle weighs nearly 1 lb about 6 ounces heavier than my old saddle, heavy for a road bike, but I am ok giving up a few ounces for more comfort. The first few rides were rough. I got very sore and was uncomfortable. However, after a few rides to allow my gluteus maximus to get used to it, the seat does get very comfortable. My suggestion is if you buy and it is not comfortable right away, give it a chance and be patient. It is worth it.
Reviewed 10/2/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I bought this saddle to replace a lighter, thinner Italian saddle which was beautiful cosmetically, but was doing me no favors to my nether regions. This saddle weighs nearly 1 lb about 6 ounces heavier than my old saddle, heavy for a road bike, but I am ok giving up a few ounces for more comfort. The first few rides were rough. I got very sore and was uncomfortable. However, after a few rides to allow my gluteus maximus to get used to it, the seat does get very comfortable. My suggestion is if you buy and it is not comfortable right away, give it a chance and be patient. It is worth it.
Review by Will MurphyJury still out but so far not as comfortable as I hopedby Will MurphyCompetitive RacerFlorida1 of 1 customers found this review helpful.I am an adventure racer so I sometimes do long rides, including on rough gravel. A comfortable saddle is key. Brooks has a great reputation and this saddle was offered at a very good price. So far I have not found it to be the perfect fit for me. That said, I have had some medical issues that kept me from riding for a while. I will see if my butt and this saddle can learn to live in harmony now that I am riding more. The surface is very grippy which takes a little getting used to. If you want to shift your position you need to lift, you can't just slight with your weight on the saddle. On the plus side the saddle is zero maintenance. Waterproof and durable.
Reviewed 4/22/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Will Murphy was helpful/No, review by Will Murphy was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I am an adventure racer so I sometimes do long rides, including on rough gravel. A comfortable saddle is key. Brooks has a great reputation and this saddle was offered at a very good price. So far I have not found it to be the perfect fit for me. That said, I have had some medical issues that kept me from riding for a while. I will see if my butt and this saddle can learn to live in harmony now that I am riding more. The surface is very grippy which takes a little getting used to. If you want to shift your position you need to lift, you can't just slight with your weight on the saddle. On the plus side the saddle is zero maintenance. Waterproof and durable.
Review by BikingBillComfortable right out of the box.by BikingBillCycling EnthusiastVancouver, WAThe nose rail on my beloved leather Brooks B17 broke which I took to be a positive omen to try the (relatively) new C17 that I'd been considering anyway. On my first ride I paid attention to the saddle and how it felt. But...after a short while I realized I wasn't paying attention,everything was just fine for me right out of the box. Saddles are very personal, it might be different for you. I like not having to carry a rain cover and I like the look of the saddle on my bike.
Reviewed 2/1/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by BikingBill was helpful/No, review by BikingBill was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
The nose rail on my beloved leather Brooks B17 broke which I took to be a positive omen to try the (relatively) new C17 that I'd been considering anyway. On my first ride I paid attention to the saddle and how it felt. But...after a short while I realized I wasn't paying attention,everything was just fine for me right out of the box. Saddles are very personal, it might be different for you. I like not having to carry a rain cover and I like the look of the saddle on my bike.
Review by AnonymousBrooks C17 exceeds expectationsby AnonymousCycling Enthusiast1 of 1 customers found this review helpful.saddle. I have been searching for a new saddle for years. My current saddle is a Terry Ti Race saddle that is over 15 years old' I bought two and they are now both quite worn.
My sit bones measure 127mm and I purchased a few saddles with those dimensions in mind but none have been comfortable. Besides seated comfort I also wanted a saddle to provided support when sliding back to climb. My Terry Ti Race has a slight ramp at the back that seemed keep me from sliding too far back when climbing.
The Brooks C17 Cambium Carved is absolutely a big surprise comfort wise, and the a bonus of the Cambium surface is that I do not slide off the saddle when I slide back to climb even though the saddle is flat. I honestly believe my multi-year search for the perfect saddle ends with the Brooks C17 Cambium Carved. I plan to buy another one to ensure I am set for years into the future.
Reviewed 1/3/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
saddle. I have been searching for a new saddle for years. My current saddle is a Terry Ti Race saddle that is over 15 years old' I bought two and they are now both quite worn.
My sit bones measure 127mm and I purchased a few saddles with those dimensions in mind but none have been comfortable. Besides seated comfort I also wanted a saddle to provided support when sliding back to climb. My Terry Ti Race has a slight ramp at the back that seemed keep me from sliding too far back when climbing.
The Brooks C17 Cambium Carved is absolutely a big surprise comfort wise, and the a bonus of the Cambium surface is that I do not slide off the saddle when I slide back to climb even though the saddle is flat. I honestly believe my multi-year search for the perfect saddle ends with the Brooks C17 Cambium Carved. I plan to buy another one to ensure I am set for years into the future.
Review by Tim BNice but not for me. by Tim BCycling EnthusiastNew York 5 of 5 customers found this review helpful.A saddle is a personal choice so take what I say with a grain of salt. I wanted to like this saddle but I just could not make it work for me. I tried the regular C-17 as well as the carved. I found the carved version to be only slightly better. As much as I wanted it to be true these are not the same as a Brooks B-17. The difference is the shape. A well broken in B-17 develops more of a scoop shape (thing equestrian saddle) over time. The shape, in my opinion is what makes these saddle so comfortable. The C-17 is not that. The shape is more round. They try to replicate the scoop with the hammock effect of the rubber but unfortunately it falls short. I finally gave up on these after trying a C-17, 15, and 19 all in the carved version.
Reviewed 5/16/2019Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Tim B was helpful/No, review by Tim B was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
A saddle is a personal choice so take what I say with a grain of salt. I wanted to like this saddle but I just could not make it work for me. I tried the regular C-17 as well as the carved. I found the carved version to be only slightly better. As much as I wanted it to be true these are not the same as a Brooks B-17. The difference is the shape. A well broken in B-17 develops more of a scoop shape (thing equestrian saddle) over time. The shape, in my opinion is what makes these saddle so comfortable. The C-17 is not that. The shape is more round. They try to replicate the scoop with the hammock effect of the rubber but unfortunately it falls short. I finally gave up on these after trying a C-17, 15, and 19 all in the carved version.
Review by Anonymousgreat saddle and vegan friendlyby AnonymousDaily Commuter1 of 3 customers found this review helpful.I needed a new saddle for my bike as my old one was worn out. I had always read reviews on brooks saddles and saw they made a vegan friendly one.
I gave it a go and liked how it feels when dialed in.
Reviewed 4/19/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I needed a new saddle for my bike as my old one was worn out. I had always read reviews on brooks saddles and saw they made a vegan friendly one.
I gave it a go and liked how it feels when dialed in.