User submitted reviews
Review by markThis seat works with the way I like to position myself on my ride.by markCycling Enthusiastseattle1 of 1 customers found this review helpful.This seat allows for rotation of you upper body forward and back without discomfort in the various positions, but it is, I think, designed to keep your sit bones in the same place. I don't think you want this saddle if you move your sit bones to different locations on the saddle. Some people like to move around the saddle - I like to keep my sit bones well planted and return to the same place after standing.
Reviewed 5/31/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by mark was helpful/No, review by mark was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
This seat allows for rotation of you upper body forward and back without discomfort in the various positions, but it is, I think, designed to keep your sit bones in the same place. I don't think you want this saddle if you move your sit bones to different locations on the saddle. Some people like to move around the saddle - I like to keep my sit bones well planted and return to the same place after standing.
Review by IrishCTGreat saddle that takes the pressure off soft tissue area. by IrishCTCycling EnthusiastConnecticutIt takes a few rides getting used to, as all saddles do, but once you get it set up correctly it takes the pressure off sensitive areas. I changed my saddle on recommendation of my urologist. I was initially reluctant as I did not have a problem with my old saddle. Once I got the SMP saddle adjusted ... I found a video on line .. I was a happy I changed.
Reviewed 4/20/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by IrishCT was helpful/No, review by IrishCT was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
It takes a few rides getting used to, as all saddles do, but once you get it set up correctly it takes the pressure off sensitive areas. I changed my saddle on recommendation of my urologist. I was initially reluctant as I did not have a problem with my old saddle. Once I got the SMP saddle adjusted ... I found a video on line .. I was a happy I changed.
Review by ChiBikerSuper comfortable!by ChiBikerCycling EnthusiastChicago, ILAfter trying countless saddles I have finally found the one. Hands down the most comfortable saddle for me. A little heavier than others but I'll take that tradeoff.
Reviewed 6/10/2021Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by ChiBiker was helpful/No, review by ChiBiker was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
After trying countless saddles I have finally found the one. Hands down the most comfortable saddle for me. A little heavier than others but I'll take that tradeoff.
Review by AnonymousComfortable for long rides sitting more upright.by AnonymousCycling EnthusiastPortland, OR1 of 1 customers found this review helpful.Wide enough to provide padded support for my sit-bones riding in a less aggressive, more upright position. Very comfortable for long rides.
Reviewed 8/24/2018Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Wide enough to provide padded support for my sit-bones riding in a less aggressive, more upright position. Very comfortable for long rides.
Review by Fran Seems like a comfy saddleby Fran Casual CyclistReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle2 of 2 customers found this review helpful.Got this saddle after purchasing a Trek Verve (upright riding). I was using my Brooks saddle, which love very much. No matter how many adjustments the saddle would not get comfortable. Sad, so put it back on my other bike which is a crank forward model. I only gave it a four star because it's just been a few rides and the verdict is still out. Nevertheless, it is more comfortable on the private parts. I'm sure will like it more after I get acclimated to the new ride and saddle.
Reviewed 8/3/2016Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Fran was helpful/No, review by Fran was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Got this saddle after purchasing a Trek Verve (upright riding). I was using my Brooks saddle, which love very much. No matter how many adjustments the saddle would not get comfortable. Sad, so put it back on my other bike which is a crank forward model. I only gave it a four star because it's just been a few rides and the verdict is still out. Nevertheless, it is more comfortable on the private parts. I'm sure will like it more after I get acclimated to the new ride and saddle.
Review by Mario SerranoVery comfortable seat for two-hour ridesby Mario SerranoAliso Viejo California Review for Selle SMP TRK SaddleThe most comfortable seat I have used. Also looks very different than seats out there. When I am parked it gets attention; people always ask how I like the seat.
Reviewed 1/19/2015Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Mario Serrano was helpful/No, review by Mario Serrano was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
The most comfortable seat I have used. Also looks very different than seats out there. When I am parked it gets attention; people always ask how I like the seat.
Review by AnonymousA great design, makes a noticeable differenceby AnonymousCycling EnthusiastHorseheads, NYReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle6 of 6 customers found this review helpful.I'm 50 years old, 202 lbs and have been cycling for only the past two years, initially for weight loss exercise but now for pure enjoyment. With the stock seat on my Giant Rapid, I found discomfort in the groin area when rides were greater than 30 miles. My younger biking colleagues convinced me to try this seat as they found improvement with use. I have used the seat for numerous rides over 25-30 miles now and wow, I experience none or minimal discomfort during and after rides. I was truly surprised and impressed how well this works. Price is reasonable and quality is good. As a note, I fiddled with the installation position and found a slight nose down incidence provided the best comfort (flat bar road bike). No issues with order, would use WB for future purchases.
Reviewed 10/26/2014Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I'm 50 years old, 202 lbs and have been cycling for only the past two years, initially for weight loss exercise but now for pure enjoyment. With the stock seat on my Giant Rapid, I found discomfort in the groin area when rides were greater than 30 miles. My younger biking colleagues convinced me to try this seat as they found improvement with use. I have used the seat for numerous rides over 25-30 miles now and wow, I experience none or minimal discomfort during and after rides. I was truly surprised and impressed how well this works. Price is reasonable and quality is good. As a note, I fiddled with the installation position and found a slight nose down incidence provided the best comfort (flat bar road bike). No issues with order, would use WB for future purchases.
Review by Bellevue riderDid STP in one day on this and it was awesomeby Bellevue riderCasual CyclistBellevue, WAReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle6 of 6 customers found this review helpful.Finished STP 2014 in 1 day on this saddle and I would say everything hurt except my butt. This is my 4th saddle I've tried this year and it'll stay on my bike for awhile. Love the shape and cut out on this thing. Highly recommended if you are doing any long distance riding.
Reviewed 7/13/2014Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Bellevue rider was helpful/No, review by Bellevue rider was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Finished STP 2014 in 1 day on this saddle and I would say everything hurt except my butt. This is my 4th saddle I've tried this year and it'll stay on my bike for awhile. Love the shape and cut out on this thing. Highly recommended if you are doing any long distance riding.
Review by Seattle noobWHAT A DIFFERENCEby Seattle noobCasual CyclistSeattle WAReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle8 of 8 customers found this review helpful.My Cannondale synapse 6 came with a Prologo kappa saddle and I was in pain after 15-20 miles of riding, endured this for 3 weekends of long distance riding when a friend of mine suggested I switch to the selle SMP Extra, Tried out this one instead, And MAN WHAT A HUGE F'ing DIFFERENCE. Its night and day, I don't even feel any pain whatsoever. Wouldn't have minded paying 2-3 times as much for this kind of immediate pain relief.
Reviewed 6/10/2013Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Seattle noob was helpful/No, review by Seattle noob was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
My Cannondale synapse 6 came with a Prologo kappa saddle and I was in pain after 15-20 miles of riding, endured this for 3 weekends of long distance riding when a friend of mine suggested I switch to the selle SMP Extra, Tried out this one instead, And MAN WHAT A HUGE F'ing DIFFERENCE. Its night and day, I don't even feel any pain whatsoever. Wouldn't have minded paying 2-3 times as much for this kind of immediate pain relief.
Review by whippetgoodi like this seatby whippetgoodCycling EnthusiastSpokane, waReview for Selle SMP TRK SaddleThis was the 5th seat I have tried and so far it is the most comfortable. I have about a hundred miles on it and it gets more comfortable each ride. The cut out works well. And the seat seems well made. Hopefully this will be my last seat for a while.
Reviewed 4/4/2013Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by whippetgood was helpful/No, review by whippetgood was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
This was the 5th seat I have tried and so far it is the most comfortable. I have about a hundred miles on it and it gets more comfortable each ride. The cut out works well. And the seat seems well made. Hopefully this will be my last seat for a while.
Review by KenGreat saddleby KenCycling EnthusiastNorth SeattleReview for Selle SMP TRK SaddleI found this to be a very comfortable saddle. Rode the STP without a complaint.
Reviewed 8/13/2012Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Ken was helpful/No, review by Ken was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I found this to be a very comfortable saddle. Rode the STP without a complaint.
Review by AnonymousSaddle did as it was supposed to, didn't notice it.by AnonymousCycling EnthusiastSeattle areaReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle3 of 3 customers found this review helpful.Bought this saddle on a recommendation from a colleague at work. Have struggled for years looking for a replacement for my old leather Brooks. This is it. Did back to back centuries last week-end and the saddle was not there, no pain or discomfort other than 7.5 hours in the saddle. Saddle did it's job.
Haven't dealt with Western Bike before. Called the sales person who was refreshingly knowledgeable and he assured me the saddle would go out that afternoon. Wife called the next day to say it had arrived. That's what I call service.
Reviewed 7/17/2012Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Bought this saddle on a recommendation from a colleague at work. Have struggled for years looking for a replacement for my old leather Brooks. This is it. Did back to back centuries last week-end and the saddle was not there, no pain or discomfort other than 7.5 hours in the saddle. Saddle did it's job.
Haven't dealt with Western Bike before. Called the sales person who was refreshingly knowledgeable and he assured me the saddle would go out that afternoon. Wife called the next day to say it had arrived. That's what I call service.
Review by klysengrVery comfortable, well constructed cut-away saddleby klysengrCycling EnthusiastSunnyvale, CAReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle2 of 2 customers found this review helpful.I replaced a Brooks B-17 leather saddle with this Selle SMP TRK saddle on my Motobecane, Century Team, road bike. The TRK has approximately the same width as the B-17 and is just as comfortable. I purchased this TRK based on the cut-away feature to see if it would relieve my numbness in my hands during longer rides. It did not help this condition, but it is well made with nice cushioning, so I will continue to use it. For the price, I highly recommend it to riders looking for a wider, well made cut- away saddle.
Reviewed 6/28/2012Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by klysengr was helpful/No, review by klysengr was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I replaced a Brooks B-17 leather saddle with this Selle SMP TRK saddle on my Motobecane, Century Team, road bike. The TRK has approximately the same width as the B-17 and is just as comfortable. I purchased this TRK based on the cut-away feature to see if it would relieve my numbness in my hands during longer rides. It did not help this condition, but it is well made with nice cushioning, so I will continue to use it. For the price, I highly recommend it to riders looking for a wider, well made cut- away saddle.
Review by AnonymousThis solved a problem that I had been addressing by riding a noseless saddle, and provides the stability of a conventional saddle!by AnonymousCycling EnthusiastPiedmont NCReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle6 of 6 customers found this review helpful.I use this on an aluminum-frame road bike, riding mostly 20-40 miles at a time but occasionally longer. The shape does what it advertises it has eliminated pineal nerve problems and chafing, but provides a comfortable platform. The sloping nose allows me to ride in the drops without discomfort. It's a bit more padded than most saddles, but not plush. The price is reasonable, especially compared to Selle's higher-end models. I couldn't be more pleased!
Reviewed 4/13/2012Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Anonymous was helpful/No, review by Anonymous was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I use this on an aluminum-frame road bike, riding mostly 20-40 miles at a time but occasionally longer. The shape does what it advertises it has eliminated pineal nerve problems and chafing, but provides a comfortable platform. The sloping nose allows me to ride in the drops without discomfort. It's a bit more padded than most saddles, but not plush. The price is reasonable, especially compared to Selle's higher-end models. I couldn't be more pleased!
Review by RickThe shape is different!by RickCycling EnthusiastMountains of East TennesseeReview for Selle SMP TRK Saddle3 of 4 customers found this review helpful.This seat is for my stoker who has never been happy about any of her tandem seats. She's not complained about this one yet. The proof will be how it works this summer after 6 or 7 hours in the saddle.
I tried out the Selle SMP pro for myself and liked it a lot. Feels weird at first since all your weight is on the sit bones. After awhile you forget about the seat, and that is the best compliment I have ever made about a saddle.
This model is quite wide and has plenty of padding. I think it is most suitable for women who prefer wider and softer.
Reviewed 2/22/2012Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Rick was helpful/No, review by Rick was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
This seat is for my stoker who has never been happy about any of her tandem seats. She's not complained about this one yet. The proof will be how it works this summer after 6 or 7 hours in the saddle.
I tried out the Selle SMP pro for myself and liked it a lot. Feels weird at first since all your weight is on the sit bones. After awhile you forget about the seat, and that is the best compliment I have ever made about a saddle.
This model is quite wide and has plenty of padding. I think it is most suitable for women who prefer wider and softer.
Review by PBCured my numbnessby PBCycling EnthusiastChicago North ShoreThis is my 3rd TRK. This seat cures my perineal numbness. The 1st 2 lasted about 6,000 KM each before the numbness came back. I rode Avocet, Brooks Imperial, an Aliante from an illiterately named brand, and an ISM Tri seat before trying the TRK. The best was the Brooks, which kept the numbness away for about 12 miles, but this works into the 40s for me. I do not mean to guarantee it will work for you, but if you're uncomfortable on your saddle, my reco is to consider the TRK, especially if numbness is a problem for you.
I've been riding about 1,300 miles a year on flat land. I'm overweight and 79 years of age.
Reviewed 8/10/2023Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by PB was helpful/No, review by PB was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
This is my 3rd TRK. This seat cures my perineal numbness. The 1st 2 lasted about 6,000 KM each before the numbness came back. I rode Avocet, Brooks Imperial, an Aliante from an illiterately named brand, and an ISM Tri seat before trying the TRK. The best was the Brooks, which kept the numbness away for about 12 miles, but this works into the 40s for me. I do not mean to guarantee it will work for you, but if you're uncomfortable on your saddle, my reco is to consider the TRK, especially if numbness is a problem for you.
I've been riding about 1,300 miles a year on flat land. I'm overweight and 79 years of age.
Review by MTSMy Touring Saddleby MTSBeautiful CaliforniaI bought a touring bike and needed a touring saddle for the more upright position. Bike tourists can wax rhapsodic all day about their Brooks saddles but I need that Selle SMP channel and beak. I have a Pro on my road bike but I wanted something more padded for the touring bike. The choice was between the Plus and the TRK. The TRK was cheaper so I went with that and as soon as I got on it for the first time (while being fitted) I knew that this was the one. It fits so well and is so comfortable with my more upright touring position. And I don't have to go into a panic when the rain comes down.
Reviewed 1/9/2023Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by MTS was helpful/No, review by MTS was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
I bought a touring bike and needed a touring saddle for the more upright position. Bike tourists can wax rhapsodic all day about their Brooks saddles but I need that Selle SMP channel and beak. I have a Pro on my road bike but I wanted something more padded for the touring bike. The choice was between the Plus and the TRK. The TRK was cheaper so I went with that and as soon as I got on it for the first time (while being fitted) I knew that this was the one. It fits so well and is so comfortable with my more upright touring position. And I don't have to go into a panic when the rain comes down.
Review by Joel CowanWe bought my wife a new saddle for her TREK Domaneby Joel CowanEl Paso, TXtxThe seat has made a significant difference for my wife. As a new rider the right saddle is critical to riding happiness.
Reviewed 12/1/2023Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Joel Cowan was helpful/No, review by Joel Cowan was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
The seat has made a significant difference for my wife. As a new rider the right saddle is critical to riding happiness.
Review by Joel CowanWe bought my wife a new saddle for her TREK Domaneby Joel CowanEl Paso, TXtxThe seat has made a significant difference for my wife. As a new rider the right saddle is critical to riding happiness.
Reviewed 12/1/2023Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Joel Cowan was helpful/No, review by Joel Cowan was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
The seat has made a significant difference for my wife. As a new rider the right saddle is critical to riding happiness.
Review by BrazadComfortable saddle for a great price!by BrazadCycling EnthusiastAlbany GARight now I have almost 30,000 miles in the past 5 years on 3 Selle TMP SRK saddles. I have one on my road bike, one on my gravel/dirt bike and one on my hybrid bike. Just this weekend (Memorial Day 2022) I rode 108 miles on Saturday and 70 miles on Monday without one saddle issue. This saddle combined with bibs from theblackbibs-dot-com are my happy combination!
Reviewed 5/30/2022Was this review useful to you? Yes, review by Brazad was helpful/No, review by Brazad was not helpfulThank you for your feedback.
Right now I have almost 30,000 miles in the past 5 years on 3 Selle TMP SRK saddles. I have one on my road bike, one on my gravel/dirt bike and one on my hybrid bike. Just this weekend (Memorial Day 2022) I rode 108 miles on Saturday and 70 miles on Monday without one saddle issue. This saddle combined with bibs from theblackbibs-dot-com are my happy combination!